I have been part of the weight loss online community now for approximately 4 months. What has become abundantly clear to me is that women totally outnumber the men by not just a big margin, but a really huge margin! What I also notice is that women seem to have been in this community all there lives, one way or another. They support each other, listen to each other (really listen) and find inventive ways to get together and do more supporting and listening! To be a guy in this community you kind of feel like the harmless gay friend who talks about his weight and tells everybody how wonderful they are.
I think for guys we relate more too action. We can talk about action. We can talk about what we are going to do, how we are going to do it and how we did it…but not about how we felt during that time. Not to say I don’t have feelings. Things make me happy and things make me sad. For the most part I am a pretty happy (not gay) guy. The only thing that exercising and diet make me feel is hungry. It has little else to do with any other kind of feelings. So, I have nothing like that to share with the community on that level. What that means is you are now on the outside looking in.
I don’t think weight loss is just for girls. There is an awful lot of guys going to gyms all around the country. I would guess, that at anytime of the day at any gym you would probably find more guys than girls. So, obviously men are being fit and watching there weight. They just don’t find the need to talk about that experience.
When they do it takes of the form of instruction. How to exercise, what you should eat or here’s how I got these results. Actionable things.
Now I love the women that I have meet in this online community. Their stories are truly inspirational and they provide me with a huge amount of motivation on a daily basis (motivation I need by the way and hope continues after this blog). But, I can’t relate to the emotional stuff. The “I eat when I feel like this”, “I need to control my emotional eating”, etc, etc. I think we are overweight, or are struggling with weight simply because of our lifestyle not emotions. We don’t move enough anymore, we eat quick foods that are no good for us and we are after-all naturally inclined to feast not famine.
So, the solution to me is straight forward. Exercise more and eat healthy. That’s it, nothing else, it is actually that simple (for a guy). Emotions have nothing to do with it (for a guy). I have a simple problem and I am going to find the simplest solution, I don’t want to make it more than needs to be. I sometimes think that emotions being part of weight-loss is there because the gender that “talks” the most about weight-loss is heavily populated with the gender that likes to talk about feelings in the first place. Thus, weight-loss needs to all about feelings. Maybe, and I say that very genuinely, it could very well be that emotions play a great deal in weight-loss for women, I don’t argue that. My point is that for men, not so much.
So, back to my original thought process here. Where are all the guys in the online weight loss community. I really want to hear from you. I think we have a lot of offer to each other. Actionable stuff like your routine, changes you made that worked, didn’t work. Best foods before and after workouts, etc, etc. I love the ladies (clearly not gay) and want to hear more of their inspirational stories and really need the motivation that only they can provide (I am a non-gay guy who loves it when a women says he is looking great!). But, I would also like to have more guys in my online group.
I know you out there. Leave a comment about your workout, tell me how you felt!
No related posts.
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.







(c) Copyright Zeta Squared Consulting 2010. All rights reserved.
[...] Original post by The Fat Geek Blog [...]
[WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The comment’s server IP (174.132.225.204) doesn’t match the comment’s URL host IP (174.132.227.99) and so is spam.
Awesome post! I am with ya on a lot of this. I am not what you would call an emotional eater. I eat because I really like food!! BUT, I think there are emotions in the losing weight part but I think it is because I am pushing myself in new ways (in the same way college for me was emtional) My husband would totally agree with you on men & weightloss! Eat less, exercise more – that is it! hehe! I guess women try to attach emotion to everything. We are emotional creatures! I love your blog & tweets!
Thanks very much Jen. You are doing great and you are probably right that there are different emotions that you experience as the pounds come off. I am just not very in touch with them. The biggest change in folks I guess would be more self-confidence. Something many men already begin with and have too much off to start. I think of the cartoon with Homer Simpson looking in the mirror and seeing this really ripped and muscular version of himself.
Ah, you sound like my husband! Definitely not gay and just gets on with it.
Women and men differ a lot – you only need to read John Gray’s “Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus” to appreciate exactly how much we differ.
I really enjoyed reading this blog. I have always thought men have a easy time losing weight but never thought of it like that. I am a emotional eater and I also find it hard not to eat at night. Anyways, enjoyed the blog, keep up the great work.
Thanks for the comment Amanda. Not sure if men have it easier or not. But I think when we decide too, we take the work part of losing weight very seriously. In fact, I would guess, from my experience, that is all we concentrate on. As that is all what really makes sense to me. Everything else is just window dressing, or noise to distract you from the real work.